An Akron Municipal Court judge set bond Saturday for 46-year-old Calvin Hunter at $10,000. Court records don't show an attorney for the Akron man.
Akron police say Hunter turned himself in to authorities Friday after detectives signed a warrant for his arrest.
Police say Hunter signed up Dec. 10 to volunteer at the Marine Corps Reserves' Toys for Tots program at First Faith Development Corporation in Akron.
Investigators say Hunter was seen on surveillance video taking toys from a storage area that night.
Officials with First Faith Development Corp. say they have been receiving donations to help them replace the toys.
Melania Trump highlighted the spirit of giving Tuesday by sorting toys and making Christmas cards for an annual toy drive held by the U.S. Marine Corps Reserve.